© 2023 Boise State Public Radio
NPR in Idaho
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
A movie night with George Prentice event details
Check out which TWO local nonprofits are the 2023 Giving Tuesday underwriting recipients!
Since at least 2007, Idaho has ranked near the bottom when it comes to the number of doctors working in the state.The latest available data from the Association of American Medical Colleges ranks Idaho 49th among states.The Gem State had 184 doctors for every 100,000 people in 2010.There are many factors that contribute to Idaho’s physician shortage; there is limited access to medical education in Idaho, salaries tend to be lower, and it’s tougher to recruit in rural areas.In addition, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has designated 39 of Idaho’s 44 counties as Health Professional Shortage Areas.In an effort to encourage more doctors to practice in Idaho, the state subsidizes the cost of medical school for 28 students in Washington and Utah per year. It also has two incentive programs; the Rural Healthcare Access Program and the Rural Physician Incentive Program.The Rural Healthcare Access Program is a way for Idaho communities to recruit doctors by offering signing bonuses or student loan repayments, as well as developing tele-health projects and improving access to care.The Rural Physician Incentive Program is a loan repayment program for doctors who chose to practice in a rural part of the state. It’s open to doctors from all schools, though preference is given to WWAMI and University of Utah graduates. Doctors are eligible to apply for up to $50,000 of loan repayment.

Despite Doctor Shortage, Refugee Physicians Face Big Hurdles To Practicing

Amanda Peacher
Mountain West News Bureau

If you’re looking for a new primary care doctor in states like Idaho or Wyoming, good luck. Our region has some of the worst doctor shortages of all U.S. states.

There actually are trained physicians here who could help-- they’re refugees who have years of medical experience. But it’s a huge challenge for them to practice here.

When Marwan Sweedan arrived in the U.S. from Iraq in 2008, his first job was selling hotdogs at a baseball stadium. Sweedan says the job was fun. But he was maybe a little overqualified for that gig -- he had worked as a trauma surgeon in a Ramadi hospital before fleeing Iraq as a refugee.

Sweedan now lives in Boise, Idaho, and works in the patient safety department at Saint Alphonsus Hospital. He’s an infection prevention specialist. But he wants to go back to treating patients as a physician.

“Here’s the thing: Being a doctor in the United States coming as a refugee is a little bit challenging because we are not prepared for the system,” says Sweedan.

That system requires passing three huge medical exams, and often necessitates some form of clinical work in the U.S. Then, foreign doctors must apply for a multi-year medical residency program. In Idaho, residency positions are already extremely competitive, and very few refugees make the cut.

“The program directors look at us as a lost cause kind of thing,” says Sweedan.

Even though they might have years of experience under their belts, refugee doctors lack some of the key elements of a successful residency match--a degree from a well-known medical school, letters of recommendation from U.S. doctors and clinical experience that program directors can verify.

“And probably their English is kind of challenging,” says Sweedan. “There’s no way for you to say, ‘Well I’m going to neglect the Harvard graduate and take this guy.'”

Idaho ranks almost dead last for available physicians--the state is49th out of 50 for number of doctors per capita. There’s only one doctor for about every 600 Idaho residents. Wyoming and Utah are also extremely short on physicians. So, theoretically, refugee doctors like Sweedan, who have years of legitimate schooling following British medical training protocols, could help fill the gap.

Credit Amanda Peacher / Mountain West News Bureau
Mountain West News Bureau
Dr. Scott Smith helps refugee doctors with their resumes and applications as they try to find meaningful work in the U.S. "The only way to practice medicine now in the United States is [for them to] start all over," he says. "Surprisingly some of them want to do all that."

“These are people that we need to serve the communities because it is so hard to get a physician in our state,” says Doctor Scott Smith, a doctor of internal medicine with the Veterans Administration Hospital in Boise.

Smith acts as guide and mentor for refugee doctors who want to get their license or otherwise work in the medical field. He helps them with things like cover letters and interview preparation.

“The only way to practice medicine now in the United States is to start all over,” says Smith. “Surprisingly some of them want to do all that.”

Smith admits that it’s hard for refugees to compete for residencies in Idaho. Last year, the Boise VA hospital had 12 open residency positions, for which it received more than 1600 applications.

To help boost refugee doctors' chances at getting some of those positions, Marwan Sweedan formed a group through a program called Global Talent Idaho. He and other refugee doctors help connect one another to local resources and mentors. They share advice and insights about how to navigate the medical system, and they support one another at various stages in the process.

Idaho lawmakers considered a proposal in this past session that would fund more medical residencies in the state, and would raise the number of residents from 141 to 356 for the next decade. But that plan came with too high of a price tag for some lawmakers, including Idaho Governor Butch Otter. The legislature ended up funding a much smaller package that allowed for 25 new residency positions in the state. In Minnesota in 2017, the legislature approved an ambitious funding packagespecifically aimed at helping foreign doctors become licensed.

Financial considerations are a big concern for many refugees as they weigh whether or not to work toward licensing. Study materials for the medical exams often cost thousands of dollars. Foreign-trained doctors often need to enroll in costly programs to gain clinical experience in the U.S. to boost their resumes, or they might have to accept unpaid internships. And refugees must often pay these costs out of pocket, while still supporting their families. Most refugees are not eligible for federal loans, and few have enough U.S. credit history to obtain a private loan.

Ali Makki fled Iraq with his family back in 2006. Like many Iraqi doctors, Makki says he received threats from insurgents when he treated Iraqi law enforcement. “It was really dangerous to work as a doctor over there,” Makki says.

There was no question for Makki that he’d try to be a doctor when he got to the U.S. And he was lucky enough to get one of the rare residencies in Idaho. But it took him eight years of work and study to get that position, and that’s on top of his training in Iraq.

There were certain points that were really frustrating. Like, why am I doing this? I have already graduated, why can’t I just practice right away? But you have to respect the system.

For Makki, all that work was worth it. He can’t imagine being anything else except a doctor. “This is what I am made to do, and I love doing it,” he says.

Makki plans on staying right here in Idaho once he’s licensed as a physician. That scenario is a long way off for Marwan Sweedan. He’s still working on passing his U.S. medical exams.

Credit Amanda Peacher / Mountain West News Bureau
Mountain West News Bureau
To be competitive for a residency program refugee doctors like Sweedan often have to get extra degrees or do unpaid clinical work in the U.S. That's on top of years of study and work in their home countries. Marwan Sweedan is hoping to get a master's degree in public health to help him stand out to residency program directors.

After eight hours at his hospital job and two hours of a physiology class, Sweedan logs onto his study program online on a recent evening. Each daily lesson requires watching a video, taking quizzes and then studying a booklet of patient cases. It’s not something he can do on, say, his lunch break at the hospital.

“No, you have to dedicate at minimum five hours, and when I say five hours it’s five exact hours,” says Sweedan. “Every day. Even holidays.”

Sweedan’s home office is sparse and mostly filled with study books. But one thing stands out -- it’s a slightly crumpled photo, pinned above his desk: an image of an anonymous child, emaciated, picking food off the street.

Sweedan has carried the photo with him ever since he left Iraq, as a reminder for why he’s a doctor. Along with Sweedan, the photo has been through a civil war, a refugee camp in Jordan, been flown across the ocean, and been with him this past decade in the U.S.

“When I am feeling tired or down, I look at the picture and I feel at least I have a chance. This kid doesn’t have anything,” says Sweedan. “And this just reminds me of my mission. These are the people I need to serve.”

Find reporter Amanda Peacher on Twitter @amandapeacher.

Copyright 2018 Boise State Public Radio

This story was produced by the Mountain West News Bureau, a collaboration between Wyoming Public Media, Boise State Public Radio in Idaho, Yellowstone Public Radio in Montana, KUER in Salt Lake City and KRCC and KUNC in Colorado.

Amanda Peacher works for the Mountain West News Bureau out of Boise State Public Radio. She's an Idaho native who returned home after a decade of living and reporting in Oregon. She's an award-winning reporter with a background in community engagement and investigative journalism.

You make stories like this possible.

The biggest portion of Boise State Public Radio's funding comes from readers like you who value fact-based journalism and trustworthy information.

Your donation today helps make our local reporting free for our entire community.